Editorial & Source Verification Policy
History should be traceable to evidence. The Atlas distinguishes what sources say, what historians infer and what remains uncertain.
Source hierarchy
Primary records include medieval charters, letters, chronicles, administrative rolls and material evidence. Editions and translations offer access to those sources but introduce editorial choices. Modern scholarship supplies historical interpretation and context. Reference overviews can corroborate dates but are not substitutes for edition-level verification of complex claims.
Claim evidence register
Significant historical claims should link to an identifiable source or evidence ID. Where available, records should preserve author or issuing institution, document or manuscript witness, repository identifier, edition, page/folio/chapter, translation, URL, date and access limitations. A book citation without a checked page is not represented as a verified passage.
Review states
- Unreviewed: research collected but not assessed against reliable sources.
- Partially verified: major facts corroborated, while some precise passages or interpretations remain open.
- Verified: the checked claim is supported by an identified witness or scholarly evidence at the level stated.
- Disputed or unresolved: sources conflict, evidence is insufficient or the claim is a contested interpretation.
Presentation approval is distinct from source verification. An editor may approve the wording or appearance of a page while individual claims still require further review. This site's current static HTML is updated manually; metadata statuses document decisions but do not automatically prevent publication.
Uncertainty, chronology and relationships
We distinguish approximate dates from established dates, medieval allegations from independently supported events, historical persons with similar names, and possible relationships from secure familial links. Conflicting evidence is recorded openly rather than silently combined.
Use of AI
AI tools may support drafting, organizing notes or identifying leads. AI-generated writing and citations are not themselves historical evidence. New claims must be reviewed against identifiable source material, and corrections are recorded when a reference does not support the stated claim.
Copyright and cultural context
Historical texts may be public domain, but modern editions, transcriptions, photographs and translations can have separate rights. Images and long extracts are not republished without a licensing review. We aim to avoid presenting later portraits as contemporary likenesses, or a later chronicle's judgment as an unqualified fact.
Documentation and corrections
See our source directory for research context and our corrections policy for how amendments will be tracked. Policy adopted: 12 November 2026.