Lulach of Scotland
Dates: born c. 1032 – 17 March 1058 (traditional date) Position: King of Scots (Alba), 1057–1058
Summary
Lulach (Lulach mac Gille Coemgáin; died 1058) was king of Scots for a short period, conventionally 1057–1058, between Macbeth and Malcolm III of Scotland. He belonged to the ruling family of Moray. His father was Gille Coemgáin and his mother Gruoch, who later married Macbeth, making Macbeth his stepfather rather than his biological father. The Annals of Ulster identify Lulach as an over-king of Alba and record his death at the hands of Malcolm, son of Duncan, in 1058. His son Máel Snechtai remained king of Moray until 1085. Later nicknames describing Lulach as foolish or unfortunate should not override this historical evidence. 1467
Names and titles
Principal historical form: Lulach mac Gille Coemgáin (Lulach son of Gille Coemgáin); early annals call him Lulach, king of Alba or over-king of Alba. Spellings in later Latin and English texts include Lulach, Luthlach, Lulag and Lulach mac Gilla Comgain. 128
Later epithets: 'the Fool', 'the Simple' (Latin fatuus) and 'the Unfortunate' (linked to tairbith) are retrospective and sometimes hostile. They do not independently establish intellectual disability, incapacity, behaviour or any clinical fact. 68
Office: King of Scots/Alba, conventionally 1057–1058; associated with Moray's ruling kindred. The precise starting day of his kingship cannot be verified from a contemporary coronation record. 145
Life and context
Lulach is born into the ruling family of Moray
c. 1032, estimated · Lulach is born into the ruling family of Moray 146
Lulach was the son of Gille Coemgáin (also Gilla Comgáin), ruler or mormaer of Moray, and Gruoch, daughter of Boite. The Royal Family estimates his birth around 1032, the year his father died, but no contemporary birth record survives. The precise succession and titles within Moray must be read within its early medieval political context rather than through later earldom institutions. 146
Gille Coemgáin dies in the Moray conflict
1032 · Gille Coemgáin dies in the Moray conflict 46
Lulach's father Gille Coemgáin was killed in 1032 in a burning that also killed many followers. The circumstances and responsibility of the attack are debated in scholarship on Macbeth and Moray. Lulach is not recorded as taking political command in this year, and details of his childhood cannot be recovered from later dramatic treatments of Macbeth. 46
His mother Gruoch marries Macbeth
After 1032, exact date uncertain · His mother Gruoch marries Macbeth 146
Gruoch later married Macbeth, King of Scotland, Mac Bethad mac Findláech. Macbeth thereby became Lulach's stepfather. The Annals of Ulster explicitly name Lulach as son of Gille Coemgáin, so describing Macbeth as Lulach's biological father is contrary to this early evidence. Gruoch's ultimate royal ancestry and the chronology of her two marriages are debated; a definitive maternal-grandfather identification should not be invented. 146
Macbeth obtains kingship after Duncan I's death
1040 · Macbeth obtains kingship after Duncan I's death 56
Duncan I of Scotland was killed in conflict involving Macbeth in 1040, after which Macbeth became king of Alba. Lulach was already tied to the ruling household through his mother's marriage, but the surviving evidence does not place him in a specified royal office or at a particular battle during Macbeth's seventeen-year reign. 56
Moray remains central to the competing Scottish royal kindreds
1040–1057 · Moray remains central to the competing Scottish royal kindreds 69
The relationship between Moray's rulers and the kingship of Alba was not simply that of a modern county to a central government. Lulach's hereditary links and his stepfather's position gave him a route into kingship, but little direct evidence survives for his activities before 1057. Broun's interpretation of the political changes, including a possible alliance with Malcolm against Macbeth, is presented as a hypothesis, not a demonstrated personal act. 69
The Northumbrian expedition against Macbeth
1054 · The Northumbrian expedition against Macbeth 5
Siward, earl of Northumbria, campaigned against Macbeth in 1054. The expedition was a turning point in the political competition that eventually brought Duncan I's son Malcolm III of Scotland to power. It did not demonstrably kill Macbeth, who continued to be recognized as king until the conventionally dated conflict of 1057. No direct participation by Lulach in Siward's expedition is established. 5
Macbeth dies in fighting associated with Malcolm
August 1057, conventional date · Macbeth dies in fighting associated with Malcolm 1235
The traditional chronology places Macbeth's death near Lumphanan in August 1057 after renewed conflict with Malcolm, son of Duncan. However, the Annals of Ulster, Tigernach and Chronicon Scotorum record both Macbeth and Lulach under 1058 and actually list Lulach's death first. The Henry Project reviews this discrepancy. Neither the conventional 1057 date nor the annalistic ordering should be silently presented as perfectly reconciled. 1235
Lulach is recognized as king of Scots
1057–1058 · Lulach is recognized as king of Scots 126
Following Macbeth, Lulach held the kingship of Alba for a short time, conventionally from 1057 to March 1058. The annals explicitly call him king or over-king of Alba, making his historical status more secure than hostile later nicknames such as 'the Fool'. Broun describes him as the last ruler of Moray recognized as king of Scotland in Scottish king lists. The basis and geographic reach of his political support remain insufficiently documented. 126
Scone and the coronation tradition
1057, traditional inauguration setting · Scone and the coronation tradition 45
The Royal Family's biography associates Lulach's recognition and coronation with Scone and calls it the first recorded coronation of a King of Scots. This is a later tradition or retrospective claim, not an eleventh-century eyewitness ceremonial record independently checked here. Scone was a royal assembly and inauguration place before the twelfth-century monastic foundation, so it is anachronistic to describe him as crowned inside the later Scone Abbey in 1057. 45
Limits of the surviving record of government
During the short reign, c. 1057–1058 · Limits of the surviving record of government 126
No continuous collection of Lulach's royal charters, household accounts or legislative measures survives in the evidence reviewed. A reign lasting months provides few securely dated events. The absence of a fuller administrative record does not prove that he had no supporters or that his reign was fictitious; the annals explicitly recognize him as a king. 126
Lulach is killed by Malcolm, son of Duncan
1058, conventionally 17 March · Lulach is killed by Malcolm, son of Duncan 1234
The Annals of Ulster say Lulach was killed in battle by Máel Coluim mac Donnchada; the Annals of Tigernach and Chronicon Scotorum say he was killed treacherously by Malcolm, son of Duncan. The Royal Family reports the traditionally precise date 17 March 1058 and the location Essie in Aberdeenshire. The year and the involvement of Malcolm are more securely attested than the precise place, day or circumstances of the killing. 1234
Malcolm III establishes his kingship
1058 · Malcolm III establishes his kingship 56
With both Macbeth and Lulach dead, Malcolm III of Scotland secured the kingship in 1058, ending the brief reign of Macbeth's stepson. The succession was contested among powerful families, not a straightforward hereditary transfer between an unbroken line of father and eldest son. Political claims surrounding Moray did not disappear when Malcolm took the throne. 56
An Iona burial is recorded but not materially confirmed
Later regnal and burial tradition · An Iona burial is recorded but not materially confirmed 68
Later histories place Lulach's burial at Iona, a sacred place associated with several early Scottish kings. Dauvit Broun's concise scholarly account specifically notes that the Iona claim depends on a debatable source. No excavated tomb has been established here as the grave of Lulach. His burial location should therefore be labelled tradition rather than proven archaeological fact. 68
His son Máel Snechtai dies as ruler of Moray
1085 · His son Máel Snechtai dies as ruler of Moray 79
The Annals of Ulster, in their entry for 1085, name Máel Snechtai as the son of Lulach and king of Moray. This is powerful direct evidence for Lulach's paternity and for the continued political relevance of the Moray branch after he lost the Scottish kingship. It does not mean that Máel Snechtai succeeded his father as king of all Alba or held the kingdom of Scotland in 1058. 79
The later Moray succession and a debated maternal connection
1130 · The later Moray succession and a debated maternal connection 89
The king and Moray kindred continued to contest royal authority. Later genealogical histories connect Óengus (Angus), a ruler of Moray killed during rebellion against David I of Scotland in 1130, with descendants of Lulach. Older accounts call Óengus Lulach's daughter's son, while modern genealogical scholarship discusses a daughter of Máel Snechtai as the connecting generation. The chain must be left unresolved pending a claim-by-claim comparison of the manuscript witnesses. 89
Hostile bynames and the danger of reading them as diagnosis
Late medieval and early modern accounts · Hostile bynames and the danger of reading them as diagnosis 68
Later texts associate Lulach with epithets translated as 'the Fool', 'the Simple' or 'the Unfortunate'. These are literary and political judgments, not contemporary medical diagnoses or evidence of an incapacity to rule. The historical person, explicitly named as king in contemporary annals, should not be reduced to a caricature because he lost a dynastic conflict. 68
Separating Lulach from Shakespeare's Macbeth tradition
Eleventh century to modern retellings · Separating Lulach from Shakespeare's Macbeth tradition 16
Shakespeare's Macbeth transforms the history of the reign that preceded Lulach's into tragedy, but does not document Lulach's political life. A fictionalized son of Macbeth must not be merged with this real stepson, whom the early annals name by his own father Gille Coemgáin. Later paintings of medieval Scottish kings are also retrospective art rather than contemporary likenesses. 16
Date uncertainties
Birth: The Royal Family gives about 1032, but no near-contemporary record supplies an exact birth year or location; avoid assigning a fully documented birthday. 4
Accession: Conventionally after Macbeth's death in August 1057; sources differ over the chronology of Macbeth's death relative to Lulach's. The Annals of Ulster and Tigernach place their obituaries in 1058 and list Lulach first, whereas medieval king lists place him after Macbeth. 125
Reign length: A matter of months, variously described in later chronologies as approximately four to seven months. Do not invent a precise accession-day-to-death interval from conflicting sources. 568
Death: 1058 is established in several annals; 17 March 1058 and Essie in Aberdeenshire are traditional precise datings in institutional and later histories. The Ulster annalist says killed in battle, while Tigernach and Chronicon Scotorum describe treachery. 1234
Burial: Iona is a later historical tradition described by Broun as resting on debatable evidence. 6
People and dynastic connections
Family relationships
Father: Gille Coemgáin (Gillacomgan) mac Maíl Brigte, ruler/mormaer of Moray, killed in 1032. The Annals of Ulster's patronymic explicitly identifies Lulach as his son. 14
Mother: Gruoch, daughter of Boite (Bodhe), a royal-descended noblewoman who later married Macbeth. Her own earliest generations and paternal-grandfather identifications have competing reconstructions. 46
Stepfather and predecessor: Macbeth, King of Scotland, king of Scots from 1040 until the conventionally dated death in 1057, married Lulach's mother after his father's death. This step-relationship must not be replaced by a biological father–son edge. 14
Biological son: Máel Snechtai mac Lulaich, identified explicitly by the Annals of Ulster in 1085 as son of Lulach and king of Moray. No separate public profile has yet been published; do not create a broken biography link. 7
Unnamed spouse or mother of son: A marriage is plausible given Máel Snechtai's known existence, but the name and ancestry of Lulach's wife or Máel Snechtai's mother have not been independently established from the consulted sources. Do not insert a named spouse from unsourced online pedigrees. 7
Possible daughter and later kindred: An unnamed daughter is mentioned in older accounts as ancestor of Óengus of Moray (d. 1130), but modern genealogy research has questioned whether that linking woman was instead Máel Snechtai's daughter. This precise parent–child edge remains unverified and is not added to the graph. 89
Rival and successor: Malcolm III of Scotland, son of Duncan I of Scotland, is named in the early annals as the king whose forces killed Lulach in 1058; he then consolidated the Scottish kingship. 12
Moray lineage: Lulach's father and Macbeth belonged to interconnected Moray ruling families. Later genealogical texts describe kinship beyond the stepfather relationship, but the degree and route should be evaluated from the individual manuscripts rather than asserted as a definite cousin relationship in the public graph. 910
Medieval records and perspectives
Primary historical evidence: The Annals of Ulster (U1058.2) and the Annals of Tigernach (T1058.1) identify Lulach as a king and attribute his death to Malcolm, son of Duncan. The Ulster text says he was killed in battle, while Tigernach says treacherously; Chronicon Scotorum also uses the treachery characterization. They provide a solid basis for Lulach's historical kingship but not an exhaustive account of his reign. 123
Chronological conflict: The Irish annals record both Macbeth's and Lulach's deaths in 1058, with Lulach first. Later Scottish king lists and the usual modern narrative give Macbeth's death in 1057 followed by Lulach's brief reign. The Henry Project discusses incompatible witnesses and the possibility of copying or annal-year alignment errors; it does not produce a universally accepted exact reconciliation. 125
Genealogy: The Annals of Ulster U1085.1 explicitly identify Máel Snechtai as Lulach's son. Later medieval Gaelic genealogical manuscripts (including material transmitted through the 1467 manuscript) provide additional ancestry claims, but were compiled centuries afterward and must be tested against earlier annals. 7910
Modern interpretation and reception: Dauvit Broun's Oxford Companion to British History article describes Lulach's brief reign and offers a hypothesis that Lulach may previously have supported Malcolm against Macbeth; that possibility is not attested as a specific personal act in the annalistic record. The Royal Family's coronation statement at Scone and the older DNB's epithets preserve later representations, not independently established eyewitness ceremonies or character assessments. 468
Uncertainties and historical debates
Who was Lulach's father?: The Ulster annal explicitly identifies Gille Coemgáin. Macbeth was his stepfather through Gruoch's later marriage, despite some later genealogical texts that use compressed or conflicting identifications. 14
Was Lulach actually king or merely a pretender?: The early annals describe him as king or over-king of Alba; 'pretender' alone would erase a historical office recognized in the record. The degree of territorial recognition remains difficult to reconstruct. 126
Was he crowned in Scone Abbey?: The institutional biography links a coronation to Scone, but the later monastic abbey did not yet exist in its twelfth-century form. The site was an inauguration place; the exact ceremony and claim of a first recorded coronation need specialist review. 4
Did he die in battle or through treachery?: Ulster says battle; Tigernach and Chronicon Scotorum say treachery. Both witness traditions should be preserved instead of conflated into a single eyewitness account. 123
Did Macbeth die in 1057 or after Lulach in 1058?: Medieval king lists and later chronology favor 1057 Macbeth then Lulach; Irish annal ordering disagrees. This is an unresolved documentary contradiction, not a reason to silently alter an annal's recorded year. 15
Was Lulach weak-minded?: Later labels translated as Fool or Simple are rhetorical and hostile judgments. No contemporary diagnostic or clinical evidence supports treating them as facts. 68
How did the Moray descent reach Óengus?: Lulach's son Máel Snechtai is an early-attested fact; the exact maternal chain to Óengus who died in 1130 has different versions in older and recent accounts. Do not use an unverified daughter edge. 789
Historical representation — Lulach and Shakespeare's Macbeth
Lulach was a historical person and a king of Scots, not a fictional son of Macbeth invented by Shakespeare. His lineage is attested in annals that give his actual father as Gille Coemgáin. The early-modern play Macbeth does not supply testimony about his reign, political alliances, personality or children. Later literary portrayals of Moray and Macbeth may omit Lulach or change his relationship to the royal household; those adaptations must remain separate from the published historical genealogy. 124
Sources
- University College Cork, CELT, Annals of Ulster, U1058.2 and U1058.6: Lulach and Macbeth obituary notices. Digital source
- University College Cork, CELT, Annals of Tigernach, T1058.1 and T1058.5: Lulach and Macbeth deaths. Digital source
- University College Cork, CELT, Chronicon Scotorum, CS1058: Lulach and Macbeth. Digital source
- The Royal Family, “Lulach (r. 1057–1058)”, institutional overview of parentage, Scone tradition and death. Digital source
- Stewart Baldwin, The Henry Project, “Malcolm III of Scotland”, source criticism of Macbeth–Lulach succession chronology. Digital source
- Dauvit Broun, “Lulach”, The Oxford Companion to British History, reproduced in Encyclopedia.com: interpretation of the short reign and Moray genealogy. Digital source
- University College Cork, CELT, Annals of Ulster, U1085.1: obituary of Máel Snechtai son of Lulach, king of Moray. Digital source
- Dictionary of National Biography, 1885–1900, “Lulach”, via Wikisource; older secondary synthesis used as a witness to subsequent historiography, not a contemporary account. Digital source
- Dauvit Broun, “The genealogy of the king of Scots as charter and panegyric”, academic article discussing Máel Snechtai, Lulach and kindred genealogies. Digital source
- Máire and Ronnie Black, 1467 manuscript genealogy, “Lulach, King of Scotland”, transcribed medieval genealogical text; written centuries after Lulach. Digital source