Stephen of Blois
Summary
Stephen, son of Adela of Normandy, was crowned king of England after the death of his uncle Henry I in 1135. His cousin Empress Matilda had been designated as heir. Their competing claims led to years of regional conflict, until Stephen recognized Matilda's son Henry as his successor. 1 2
Names and titles
Stephen of Blois. Also recorded or known as King Stephen; Stephen of England; Étienne de Blois.
Titles and position: King of England, 1135–1154.
Life and context
From Blois to the court of Henry I
c. 1092–1096 · Stephen born into the Blois-Norman family 13
Stephen was a son of Adela of Normandy and Stephen-Henry, count of Blois, and thus a grandson of William the Conqueror. Henry of Blois, bishop of Winchester, was his brother. Stephen's precise birth year is uncertain, commonly placed around 1092–96. 1 3
Stephen was a son of Adela of Normandy and Stephen-Henry, count of Blois, and grandson of William I. Following his father's death on crusade, he benefited from his mother's family connections and from service at the court of his uncle Henry I. His brothers Theobald and Henry of Blois followed different paths in comital government and the Church. Their different roles helped shape Stephen's later political support. 8 9
Matilda of Boulogne and the resources of marriage
c. 1125 · Marriage brings the resources of Boulogne 19
Stephen married Matilda of Boulogne, who brought significant lands and political resources. Their son Eustace later became a candidate for succession. Queen Matilda acted politically in her own right, and should not be reduced to a passive supporter. 1 2
Stephen's marriage around 1125 to Matilda of Boulogne brought an important continental county and considerable English estates into their shared political world. She was a landholder and organiser of diplomacy and military support in her own right. Their son Eustace became a prospective heir, but another son William survived the 1153 settlement; the rights of the king's surviving family remained an important issue. Matilda of Boulogne must not be confused with Empress Matilda, his royal rival. 1 9
Succession oaths for Matilda
· Succession oaths for Matilda 120
Leading magnates are asked to recognize Henry I's daughter as heir; later compliance is contested.120
Why Stephen secured the crown in 1135
· Stephen crowned king 1
After Henry I died, Stephen secured supporters and was crowned at Westminster on 22 December 1135. This challenged earlier succession oaths supporting Henry's daughter Empress Matilda. Papal approval was recorded in 1136. 1 2 3
Henry I had required nobles, including Stephen, to support his daughter Empress Matilda. Yet on Henry's death in December 1135 Stephen reached England and gathered support from Londoners, influential nobles and church leaders, including his brother Henry, bishop of Winchester. He was crowned at Westminster on 22 December 1135; papal recognition followed in 1136. The events involved oaths, royal kinship, religious legitimation and access to political resources, not an agreed automatic rule of male succession. 1 8 9
The 1136 Charter of Liberties: an actual surviving document
1136 · A surviving Charter of Liberties issued 10
Stephen issued a Charter of Liberties following his Easter court in 1136. Exeter Cathedral preserves an original example with part of its wax royal seal; the cathedral reports other surviving copies at Hereford and Salisbury. The text deals with church rights and possessions, forests and established lawful customs. Its references to ecclesiastical property held at William I's death express a restoration programme, but the promise of a right and evidence that it was consistently enforced are different kinds of proof. 10
A charter for Eye Priory and the fragment of a royal seal
· Stephen confirms Eye Priory holdings 22
British Library Add Ch 75727, dated approximately December 1137–March 1138, confirms the possessions of Eye Priory in Suffolk. Its edition reference is Regesta Regum Anglo-Normannorum III, no. 288. The original document preserves only a fragment of Stephen's first royal seal, while a seventeenth-century copy in Cotton MS Vitellius F.IV, fols. 79–80v, depicts it complete. The distinction between later drawing and original parchment matters when reconstructing medieval royal documents. 6
Northern war and the Battle of the Standard
1138 · Northern war and the Battle of the Standard 911
In 1138, David I of Scotland supported the rival claim of Empress Matilda while seeking influence in northern England. An English force raised by Archbishop Thurstan of York defeated Scottish invaders near Northallerton on 22 August in the Battle of the Standard. Historic England describes a wagon carrying a mast and saints' banners at the centre of the defence. It is important not to assume Stephen personally commanded every victorious royalist force: regional allies acted in his interest. 9 11
The 1139 arrests of bishops and their castles
1139 · Bishops arrested in a dispute over castles 1213
Stephen ordered the arrest of Roger of Salisbury and Alexander of Lincoln in a confrontation over security, power and castles. William of Malmesbury's Historia novella, reproduced in an early sourcebook from the edition by Stubbs, volume II, pp. 547–555, contains a hostile narrative of the seizures and the Winchester hearing. Modern historian Kenji Yoshitake disputes the familiar claim that the episode immediately destroyed the entire royal administration: evidence indicates that numerous churchmen and officials continued attending Stephen's court before his defeat in 1141. 12 13
What government looked like in a divided kingdom
During the civil war · Government operates within a divided kingdom 914
The war did not produce the same political conditions throughout England. Stephen issued grants, appointed officers and maintained alliances where he controlled royal institutions, while opposing magnates exercised power elsewhere. Historian Heather Tanner highlights continuity from Henry I's government in some districts, even amid military violence and arbitrary demands. The absence of a complete surviving annual financial account for each year is not evidence that all courts, sheriffs and royal business suddenly ceased to exist. 9 14
Coins as evidence of changing royal power
During his reign · Coinage reflects changing political control 15
Numismatic historian Mark Blackburn identifies a more orderly currency system at the start of Stephen's reign, followed by fragmented control of minting in some areas as regional lords gained power. The central royal mint administration recovered toward the end. Coins provide evidence of political geography that narrative writers could overlook, but specific types and issues must be dated and attributed carefully. The presence of irregular coinage is not proof that every English market stopped working. 15
Lincoln in February 1141 and a queen's resistance
· Stephen captured at Lincoln 120
Empress Matilda's forces captured Stephen at the Battle of Lincoln in February 1141. Matilda gained acknowledgement as Lady of the English, while Stephen's supporters, including his queen, continued resistance. An exchange involving Robert of Gloucester enabled Stephen's restoration. Chroniclers' judgments of leaders are not neutral. 1 2
Stephen was captured after his defeat at Lincoln on 2 February 1141, permitting Empress Matilda to seek recognition as Lady of the English. But Stephen's wife Queen Matilda of Boulogne continued organising resistance, resources and military allies. Opposition in London and the fighting around Winchester eventually resulted in the capture of the empress's half-brother Robert of Gloucester. A prisoner exchange returned Stephen to freedom. Capturing one king did not transfer all castles, money, legal powers and local loyalties to the claimant. 1 9
Faversham Abbey: foundation and royal graves
1147–1148 · Faversham Abbey founded and settled 18
Stephen founded St Saviour's Abbey at Faversham in 1147 to serve as a royal burial house. Historic England dates construction and the arrival of its first monks to 1148. Matilda of Boulogne was buried there in 1152 and Stephen after his death on 25 October 1154. Historic England's record names a son buried in 1153 as ‘Eugene’, whereas the historical accounts name Stephen's intended heir Eustace as dying that year. The abbey was largely demolished after the Dissolution, but archaeology preserves evidence of its size and former religious role. Its lost tombs should not be assigned invented modern burial coordinates. 18
Beyond the stereotype of anarchy
1135–1154 · A reign of conflict and continuing government 891315
Stephen's reign was marked by civil war, castle warfare and serious harm to civilians, yet a sweeping claim that England lacked government for nineteen years conceals local variation. Modern research on royal charters, bishoprics, coins and the surviving administrative framework shows both disruption and continuity. Medieval writers who condemned the king must be read alongside documentary evidence and the limits of their regional knowledge. The task is neither to excuse violence nor to turn the whole reign into an unexamined moral judgment. 8 9 13 15
Fountains and Ramsey: continued legal transactions
· Stephen confirms Fountains grants 7
British Library Add Ch 76710 records Stephen's confirmation of gifts to Fountains Abbey at Ipswich, approximately 1151–53, and names his son Eustace among the witnesses. Its catalogue gives Regesta III, no. 336, and an associated cartulary copy in Oxford, University College MS C167, fol. 1. Add Ch 5861 concerns the hundred of Herstingestane granted to Ramsey Abbey for a stated annual payment of four marks. These records show a king conducting legal and religious business despite continuing dynastic competition, although the full charter Latin has not been independently collated. 7 16
The road to the settlement of 1153
· Stephen–Henry succession settlement 1
The death of Stephen's son Eustace in 1153 contributed to negotiations under which Matilda's son Henry became the recognized successor. Stephen died on 25 October 1154 and was succeeded by Henry II. 1 2 3
The empress's son Henry returned to England with substantial Norman and Angevin resources and a claim strengthened by marriage to Eleanor of Aquitaine. Stephen tried to ensure his son Eustace would succeed him, including an unsuccessful proposal for Eustace's coronation. After Eustace died in 1153, negotiations following a confrontation near Wallingford produced a settlement confirmed at Winchester. Stephen remained king for life and recognised Henry as successor, while his surviving son William retained family interests. 1 9 17
How a contemporary chronicler described the peace
1153 · Henry of Huntingdon describes the succession peace 121719
The 1153 agreement is represented in Henry of Huntingdon's Historia Anglorum, edited by Thomas Arnold, p. 289, in A. E. Bland's historical source collection. It describes Archbishop Theobald mediating between the king and Henry and subsequent homage that preserved Stephen's position for his lifetime. This is an identifiable edited narrative with its author's political perspective, not an authenticated transcript of a single modern-style treaty document. J. C. Holt's specialist research investigates the pact's wider inheritance and legal consequences. A separate, later-twelfth-century account by William of Newburgh, book I chapter 30, links Eustace's death with the opportunity for a negotiated peace; this is a chronicle interpretation, not a signed treaty. 12 17 19
Stephen dies; Henry II succeeds
· Stephen dies; Henry II succeeds 1
Stephen dies at Dover; Henry II succeeds, ending the immediate crown succession dispute.1
Date uncertainties
Stephen’s birth is variously estimated around 1092 or 1096. His coronation on 22 December 1135 is much more closely dated. The political changes of 1141 did not produce a simple, uniform transfer of allegiance throughout England, even where retrospective regnal tables imply one.139
People and dynastic connections
Family relationships
Parents: Stephen-Henry of Blois, Adela of Normandy13
Medieval records and perspectives
The British Library identifies Add Ch 75727, a charter issued by Stephen to Eye Priory in about 1137–1138 and indexed as Regesta Regum Anglo-Normannorum III, no. 288. A later copy is recorded as Cotton MS Vitellius F.IV, fols. 79–80v. Two further records are Add Ch 76710, a Fountains Abbey confirmation issued at Ipswich around 1151–53 (Regesta III no. 336; Early Yorkshire Charters I no. 73, copied in Oxford, University College MS C167 fol. 1), and Add Ch 5861 (Ramsey Abbey). Stephen's original Eye Priory seal survives only as a fragment; the complete seal is recorded in a later copy. British Library charter catalogue.
Edmund King’s Oxford Dictionary of National Biography entry on Stephen confirms his approximate birth dates and his parentage as a son of Stephen-Henry of Blois and Adela of Normandy.
Uncertainties and historical debates
“The Anarchy” is a later label for a civil war whose intensity and political conditions varied by region. Charters, seals and coinage show continued government alongside violence. The rival claims of Stephen and the empress, and the eventual settlement in Henry’s favour, cannot be reduced to one universally accepted rule of succession.131213
Sources
- The Royal Family, “Stephen and Matilda (r.1135–1154)”. Digital source. ↩
- Historic Royal Palaces, “Kings and Queens of England and Britain”, Stephen and Matilda sections. Digital source. ↩
- Archontology, “Stephen of Blois”. Digital source. ↩
- Dictionary of National Biography, Stephen (older biographical scholarship). Digital source.
- Judith Green, Henry I: King of England and Duke of Normandy (Cambridge, 2006). Digital source.
- British Library, Add Ch 75727, Stephen’s Eye Priory charter, c. December 1137–March 1138; Regesta Regum Anglo-Normannorum III (1968), no. 288; later copy Cotton MS Vitellius F.IV ff. 79–80v. Digital source. ↩
- British Library, Add Ch 76710 (Fountains Abbey confirmation, c.1151–53) and Add Ch 5861 (Ramsey Abbey hundred); Fountains archival page. Digital source; Related digital source. ↩
- Edmund King, “Stephen (c. 1092–1154), king of England”, Oxford Dictionary of National Biography. Digital source. ↩
- Heather Tanner, ‘King Stephen and The Anarchy: A Reign Reconsidered’, Ohio State University Origins, modern interpretive synthesis of queen, regional governance, 1138, 1141 and 1153. Digital source. ↩
- Exeter Cathedral, ‘From the Archives: The Charter of Liberties’ (2023), original surviving 1136 Stephen charter, seal fragment, and other cathedral copies. Digital source. ↩
- Historic England, registered battlefield ‘Battle of Northallerton 1138’, list entry 1000027, battle context and local army under Archbishop Thurstan. Digital source. ↩
- A. E. Bland (ed.), The Normans in England (1914), translated excerpts from William of Malmesbury Historia novella ed. Stubbs II pp. 547–555 (1139 bishops); William of Malmesbury and Henry of Huntingdon ed. Arnold p. 289 (1153 peace). Digital source. ↩
- Kenji Yoshitake, ‘The arrest of the bishops in 1139 and its consequences’, Journal of Medieval History 14 (1988) pp. 97–114, DOI 10.1016/0304-4181(88)90022-X. Digital source. ↩
- The National Archives, ‘Medieval political history’ research guide, medieval Exchequer records and Pipe Roll series E 372, institutional general overview. Digital source. ↩
- Mark Blackburn, ‘Coinage and Currency’, in Edmund King (ed.), The Anarchy of King Stephen’s Reign (1994), pp. 145–206, DOI 10.1093/acprof:oso/9780198203643.003.0006; accessible academic abstract. Digital source. ↩
- British Library, catalogue of Add Ch 5861: Stephen confirmation to Ramsey Abbey of the hundred of Herstingestane, with four-mark annual payment; medieval act not independently transcribed. Digital source; Related digital source. ↩
- J. C. Holt, ‘1153: The Treaty of Winchester’, in Edmund King (ed.), The Anarchy of King Stephen’s Reign (1994), pp. 291–316, DOI 10.1093/acprof:oso/9780198203643.003.0010; specialist abstract. Digital source. ↩
- Historic England, St Saviour’s Abbey Faversham scheduled monument, list 1011804: royal foundation 1147, building from 1148, burials and later archaeology. Digital source. ↩
- William of Newburgh, Historia rerum Anglicarum, Book I, chapter 30, “Of the treaty between king Stephen and prince Henry,” translated edited text in Fordham University’s Internet Medieval Sourcebook. Digital source. ↩
- Marjorie Chibnall, “Matilda [Matilda of England] (1102–1167), empress”, Oxford Dictionary of National Biography. Digital source. ↩
- The Royal Family, Henry I ‘Beauclerc’ (r. 1100–1135). Digital source. ↩
- British Library Add Ch 75727: King Stephen's Eye Priory charter. Digital source↩
- Columbia University, Epistolae, “Matilda of Boulogne, queen of England,” biography and correspondence index. Digital source. ↩
- Patricia A. Dark, The Career of Matilda of Boulogne as Countess and Queen in England, 1135–1152 (University of Oxford DPhil, 2005), Oxford Research Archive. Digital source. ↩
- Dictionary of National Biography (1885–1900), “Matilda of Boulogne,” public-domain historical biography. Digital source. ↩